The Ethnic and the Religious in the Old Believers Question in the Mid–Late 19th Century

Verniaev, Igor

English

Home>Issue 3>The Ethnic and the Religious in the Old Believers Question in the Mid–Late 19th Century

The Ethnic and the Religious in the Old Believers Question in the Mid–Late 19th Century

Table of contents

Annotation Estimate Publication content

References Comments

The Ethnic and the Religious in the Old Believers Question in the Mid–Late 19th Century

Annotation

PII

S0869-54150000339-5-1

Publication type

Article

Status

Published

Authors

Igor Verniaev Send message

ORCID: 0000-0002-1540-381X

Edition

Issue 3

Pages

98-113

Abstract

The article examines the changes in the image of the Old Believers in the governmental and intellectual circles of Russia in the mid–late 19th century. These changes were connected with the transformation of the main categorizations of the empire’s population. Official religious and social categorizationswere gradually losing their importance against the backdrop of strengthening of the importance of ethnic classification of the imperial diversity, and actualization of ethnic categories in governmental discourses and practices. The factor of the Old Believers’ schism was becoming less of an issue in the new context. Ideas on the Old Believers as the most stable Russian ethnic element, ethnic-cultural “core” of the Russian people, and the ally of the empire in the implementation of integration policy in the outskirts were simultaneously strengthening. The new notions and persistence of traditional views defined a compromise nature of legislation in the 1870–1880s with regard to the Old Believers.

Keywords

Russian Empire, nineteenth century, Old Believers, policies, religious and ethnic categorization, legislation on Old Believers

Date of publication

01.05.2018

Number of purchasers

Views

546

Readers community rating

0.0 (0 votes)

Cite Download pdf

GOST	Verniaev I. The Ethnic and the Religious in the Old Believers Question in the Mid–Late 19th Century // Ethno review. – 2018. – Issue 3 C. 98-113 .
MLA	Verniaev, Igor "The Ethnic and the Religious in the Old Believers Question in the Mid–Late 19th Century." Ethno review. 3 (2018).:98-113.
APA	Verniaev I. (2018). The Ethnic and the Religious in the Old Believers Question in the Mid–Late 19th Century. Ethno review. no. 3, pp.98-113

Additional services access

Additional services for the article

Services benefits

100 RUB / 1.0 SU


1

References

Additional sources and materials




Aksakov 1882 – Aksakov I.S. Po povodu stat'i V.S. Solov'eva “O tserkvi i raskole” // Rus'. 2.10.1882. № 40. S. 1–3.
Aksakov 1888 – Aksakov I.S. Zapiska o bessarabskikh raskol'nikakh // Russkij arkhiv. 1888. Kn. 3. S. 434–451.
Aksakov 1988 – Aksakov I.S. Pis'ma k rodnym (1844–1849). T. 1. M.: Nauka, 1988.
Anuchin 1893 – Anuchin D.G. Graf Fedor Fedorovich Berg, namestnik v Tsarstve Pol'skom (1863–1874): materialy dlya istorii usmireniya myatezha 1863–1864 g. i posledovavshikh zatem preobrazovanij v Privislyanskom krae. Ch. X–XII // Russkaya starina. 1893. № 3. S. 559–573.
Vvedenskij 1912 – Vvedenskij A.P. Dejstvuyuschie zakonopolozheniya kasatel'no staroobryadtsev i sektantov. Odessa: Tipografiya “Odesskikh novostej”, 1912.
Gakstgauzen 1869 – Gakstgauzen A. Issledovaniya vnutrennikh otnoshenij narodnoj zhizni i v osobennosti sel'skikh uchrezhdenij Rossii barona Avgusta Gakstgauzena. T. 1. M.: Izdatel' L.I. Ragozin, Tipografiya A.I. Mamontova i K°, 1869.
Gilyarov-Platonov 1905 – Gilyarov-Platonov N.P. Voprosy very i tserkvi. Sbornik statej 1868–1887 gg. Izdanie K.P. Pobedonostseva. T. 1. M.: Sinodal'naya tipografiya, 1905.
Izvekov 1899 – Izvekov N.D. Istoricheskij ocherk sostoyaniya Pravoslavnoj Tserkvi v Litovskoj eparkhii za vremya 1839–1889 g. M.: Pechatnya A.I. Snegirevoj, 1899.
Karlovich 1881 – Karlovich V.M. Istoricheskie issledovaniya, sluzhaschie k opravdaniyu staroobryadtsev. T. 1. M.: Tipografiya A. Malyukova i Ko, 1881.
Katkov 1897 – Katkov M.N. Sobranie peredovykh statej “Moskovskikh vedomostej”. 1863 god.M: Izdanie S.P. Katkovoj, 1897.
Kryzhanovskij 1911 – Kryzhanovskij E.M. Russkoe Zabuzh'e: (Kholmschina i Podlyash'e). SPb.: Tipografiya “Mirnyj trud”, 1911.
Kuvajtsev 1886 – Kuvajtsev N.G. Novye zakony o raskol'nikakh // Yuridicheskij vestnik. 1886. T. 21. Kn. 4. № 4. C. 770–780.
Leont'ev 1886 – Leont'ev K.N. Vostok, Rossiya i slavyanstvo. Sbornik statej. T. 2. M.: Tipografiya I.N. Kushnereva, 1886.
Mel'gunov 1907 – Mel'gunov S.P. Staroobryadtsy i svoboda sovesti (Istoricheskij ocherk). M.: Tipografiya G. Lissnera i D. Sobko. M., 1907.
Nadezhdin 1860 – Nadezhdin N.I. O zagranichnykh raskol'nikakh // Sbornik pravitel'stvennykh svedenij o raskol'nikakh. Vyp. 1 / Pod red. V.I. Kel'sieva. London: Trubner&Co.; Paternoster Row, E.C., 1860. S. 139–175.
Novyj zakon 1883 – Novyj zakon o raskol'nikakh // Vestnik Evropy. 1883. T. 4. S. 352–359.
PSZ – Polnoe sobranie zakonov Rossijskoj imperii. Sobranie vtoroe. T. 49. Ch. 1. 1874 g. № 53391. SPb., 1876. S. 652–656.
Rejsner 1900a – Rejsner M.A. Veroterpimost' i natsional'nyj printsip po dejstvuyuschemu pravu. Yuridiko-dogmaticheskie ocherki // Vestnik prava. Zhurnal Yuridicheskogo obschestva pri Imperatorskom S.‑ Peterburgskom universitete. 1900. T. 30. № 4–5. C. 1–49.
Rejsner 1900b – Rejsner M.A. Moral', pravo i religiya po dejstvuyuschemu zakonu (Yuridiko-dogmaticheskie ocherki). T. III: Religioznaya politsiya i veroispovednoe prikreplenie lichnosti // Vestnik prava. Zhurnal Yuridicheskogo obschestva pri Imperatorskom S.‑ Peterburgskom universitete. 1900. T. 30. № 8. C. 1–34.
Stebnitskij 1863 – Stebnitskij M. S lyud'mi drevnego blagochestiya. M.; SPb.: Tipografiya P.A. Kulisha, 1863.
Subbotin 1881 – Subbotin N.I. O suschnosti i znachenii raskola v Rossii. SPb.: Sinodal'naya tipografiya, 1881.
Filaret 1886 – Filaret, mitropolit Moskovskij (Drozdov V.M.). Sobranie mnenij i otzyvov Filareta, mitropolita Moskovskogo i Kolomenskogo, po uchebnym i tserkovno-gosudarstvennym voprosam. T. 4. SPb.: Sinodal'naya tipografiya, 1886.
Filaret 1874 – Filaret, mitropolit Moskovskij (Drozdov V.M.). Sochineniya Filareta, mitropolita Moskovskogo i Kolomenskogo. Slova i rechi. T. 2. M.: Tipografiya A.I. Mamontova i K°, 1874.
Schapov 1859 – Schapov A.P. Russkij raskol staroobryadstva, rassmatrivaemyj v svyazi s vnutrennim sostoyaniem Russkoj tserkvi i grazhdanstvennosti v XVII v. i v pervoj polovine XVIII v. Kazan': Izdanie knigoprodavtsa Ivana Dubrovina, 1859.
Schapov 1862 – Schapov A.P. Zemstvo i raskol. Vyp. 1. SPb.: Tipografiya Tovarischestva “Obschestvennaya pol'za”, 1862.
Yasevich-Borodaevskaya 1912 – Yasevich-Borodaevskaya V.I. Bor'ba za veru. Istoriko-bytovye ocherki i obzor zakonodatel'stva po staroobryadchestvu i sektantstvu v ego posledovatel'nom razvitii s prilozheniem statej zakona i Vysochajshikh ukazov. SPb.: Gosudarstvennaya tipografiya, 1912.
Bendin A.Yu. Pol'skij myatezh 1863 g. v sud'bakh staroobryadtsev Severo-Zapadnogo kraya Rossijskoj imperii // Vestnik Rossijskogo universiteta druzhby narodov. 2011. № 1. C. 77–92.
Bendin A.Yu. Staroobryadtsy i rossijskaya veroterpimost' v XIX – nachale XX v. // Staroobryadchestvo: istoriya, kul'tura, sovremennost' / Pod red. V.I. Osipova i dr. T. 1. M.: Tsentr istorii i kul'tury staroobryadchestva, 2014. C. 147–160.
Vert P. “Natsionalizatsiya” religii v Rossijskoj imperii v XIX – nachale KhKh veka // Proniknovenie i primenenie diskursa natsional'nosti v Rossii i SSSR v kontse XVIII – pervoj polovine XX vv. / Pod red. I. Yaatsa, Eh. Tammiksaara. Tartu: Ehstonskij natsional'nyj muzej, 2011. S. 17–27.
Gorizontov L.E. Raskol'nichij klin. Pol'skij vopros i staroobryadtsy v imperskoj strategii // Slavyanskij al'manakh 1997 / Otv. red. M.A. Robinson. M.: Indrik, 1998. C. 140–167.
Dolbilov M.D. Russkij kraj, chuzhaya vera. Ehtnokonfessional'naya politika imperii v Litve i Belorussii pri Aleksandre II. M.: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, 2010.
Dolgov K.M. Voskhozhdenie na Afon. Zhizn' i mirosozertsanie Konstantina Leont'eva. M.: Otchij dom, 2008.
Dorskaya A.A. Realizatsiya veroispovednogo zakonodatel'stva v Severo-Zapadnom krae Rossijskoj imperii (na primere deyatel'nosti M.N. Murav'eva) // Vestnik Moskovskogo gorodskogo pedagogicheskogo universiteta. 2017. № 1 (25). S. 15–24.
Ershova O.P. Staroobryadchestvo i vlast'. M.: Unikum-Tsentr, 1999.
Zen'kovskij S.A. Russkoe staroobryadchestvo. M.: Institut DI-DIK; Kvadriga, 2009.
Kozhurin A.Ya., Kozhurin K.Ya. Staroobryadchestvo v rabotakh russkikh konservatorov vtoroj poloviny KhIKh – nachala KhKh veka // Izvestiya Sankt-Peterburgskogo gosudarstvennogo agrarnogo universiteta. 2014. № 36. C. 277–284.
Nikol'skij N.M. Istoriya russkoj tserkvi. M.: Politizdat, 1988.
Stalyunas D. Ehtnopoliticheskaya situatsiya Severo-Zapadnogo kraya v otsenke M.N. Murav'eva (1863–1865) // Baltijskij arkhiv. Russkaya kul'tura v Pribaltike. Vyp. VII / Pod red. P. Lavrintsa. Vil'nyus: Russkie tvorcheskie resursy Baltii; Žvaigždzių miestas, 2002. S. 250–271.
Stejnvedel Ch. Sozdanie sotsial'nykh grupp i opredelenie sotsial'nogo statusa individuuma: identifikatsiya po sosloviyu, veroispovedaniyu i natsional'nosti v kontse imperskogo perioda v Rossii // Rossijskaya imperiya v zarubezhnoj istoriografii. Raboty poslednikh let: antologiya / Pod red. P. Verta, P.S. Kabytova, A.I. Millera. M.: Novoe izdatel'stvo, 2005. C. 610–633.
Taranets S.V. Staroobryadchestvo v Rossijskoj imperii (konets XVII – nachalo XX veka). T. 1. Kiev: Vipol, 2012.
Teslya A.A. “Pol'skij vopros” v peredovitsakh M.N. Katkova v “Moskovskikh vedomostyakh” v 1863 g. // Uchenye zametki Tikhookeanskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. 2011. T. 2. № 2. S. 86–97.
Yurkin I.N. Gosudarstvo i staroobryadtsy v pervoj treti XVIII veka: dejstvitel'no li Imperiya borolas' s raskol'nikami? // Chelovek mezhdu Tsarstvom i Imperiej: sb. materialov mezhdunarodnoj konferentsii / Pod red. M.S. Kiselevoj. M.: Institut cheloveka RAN, 2003. S. 350–366.
Yaats I. Torzhestvo ehtnichnosti. Vvedenie // Proniknovenie i primenenie diskursa natsional'nosti v Rossii i SSSR v kontse XVIII – pervoj polovine XX vv. / Pod red. I. Yaatsa, Eh. Tammiksaara. Tartu: Ehstonskij natsional'nyj muzej, 2011. S. 5–15.
Kappeler A. Russia as Multi-Ethnic Empire: Classifying People by Estate, Religion and Ethnicity, 1760–1855 // Defining Self: Essays on Emergent Identities in Russia, Seventeenth to Nineteenth Centuries / Ed. M. Branch. Helsinki: Finnish Literature Society, 2009. P. 59–74.
Marsden T. Afanasii Shchapov and the Significance of Religious Dissent in Imperial Russia, 1848–70. Stuttgart: ibidem-Verlag, 2008.
Marsden T. The Crisis of Religious Toleration in Imperial Russia: Bibikov’s System for the Old Believers, 1841–1855. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2015.
Sunderland W. Russians into Iakuts? “Going Native” and Problems of Russian National Identity in the Siberian North, 1870s–1914 // Slavic Review. 1996. Vol. 55. No 4. P. 806–825.
Verniaev I.I. The Russian Policy of Estate, Civil, and Confessional Integration of the Supporters of “Old Belief” in the Second Half of the 18th to the Beginning of the 19th Century // Russian History. 2017. No 44. P. 111–132.
Werth P.W. Schism Once Removed: Sects, State Authority, and Meanings of Religious Toleration in Imperial Russia // Imperial Rule / Ed. A. Miller, A. Rieber. Budapest: CEU Press, 2004. P. 83–105.