D.A. Klementz and the Production of Knowledge about Peoples in the Russian Empire

Panchenko, Alexey

doi:10.31857/S50000339-5-1

English

Home>Issue 2>D.A. Klementz and the Production of Knowledge about Peoples in the Russian Empire

D.A. Klementz and the Production of Knowledge about Peoples in the Russian Empire

Table of contents

Annotation Estimate Publication content

References Comments

D.A. Klementz and the Production of Knowledge about Peoples in the Russian Empire

Annotation

PII

S0869-54150000339-5-1

DOI

10.31857/S50000339-5-1

Publication type

Article

Status

Published

Authors

Alexey Panchenko Send message

Edition

Issue 2

Pages

122-136

Abstract

The article discusses the production of knowledge about peoples in the Russian Empire in the context of debates on Orientalism and internal colonization. I argue about the three specific types of actors participating in these discourses: power, academic science, and public intellectuals. I focus on the career of D.A. Klementz who, over the course of his life, was a member of each of these groups of actors. Belonging to the milieu of pro-revolutionary intellectuals, he positioned himself as acting on behalf of the people and refused to cooperate with the government when conducting ethnographic research. When he became the de facto director of a department at the Russian Geographic Society, he acted as a representative of authorities toward the people; yet, he retained the stance of a public intellectual in matters of studying the subjects of the Russian Empire. Upon his appointment to the position of director of the Ethnography Department at the Russian Museum, he came to face the disapproval of his ethnographic theories by authorities.

Keywords

D.A. Klementz, orientalism, geopolitics, internal colonization, non-Russian, narodnik movement, Central Asia

Number of purchasers

Views

409

Readers community rating

0.0 (0 votes)

Cite Download pdf

GOST	Panchenko A. D.A. Klementz and the Production of Knowledge about Peoples in the Russian Empire // Ethno review. – 2018. – Issue 2 C. 122-136 . DOI: 10.31857/S50000339-5-1
MLA	Panchenko, Alexey "D.A. Klementz and the Production of Knowledge about Peoples in the Russian Empire." Ethno review. 2 (2018).:122-136. DOI: 10.31857/S50000339-5-1
APA	Panchenko A. (2018). D.A. Klementz and the Production of Knowledge about Peoples in the Russian Empire. Ethno review. no. 2, pp.122-136 DOI: 10.31857/S50000339-5-1

Additional services access

Additional services for the article

Services benefits

100 RUB / 1.0 SU


1

References

Additional sources and materials


 AV IVR RAN – Arkhiv vostokovedov Instituta vostochnykh rukopisej Rossijskoj akademii nauk. F. 28. Op. 1. D. 164.
 Adrianov 2007 – Pis'mo A.V. Adrianova G.N. Potaninu ot 19 noyabrya 1889 g. // Adrianov A.V. “Dorogoj Grigorij Nikolaevich…”: pis'ma G.N. Potaninu / Sost., publ. N.V. Vasen'kin. Tomsk: Izd-vo Tomskogo un-ta, 2007. S. 131–134.
 AMKM 1 – Arkhiv Minusinskogo kraevedcheskogo muzeya. OF.10681 /5.
 AMKM 2 – Arkhiv Minusinskogo kraevedcheskogo muzeya. F. 5 V.A. Kovaleva.
 Klements 1888a – Klements D. K voprosu o pogranichnykh delakh // Sibirskaya gazeta. 1888. № 32. 1 maya. S. 4–5.
 Klements 1888b – Klements D. K voprosu o pogranichnykh otnosheniyakh // Sibirskaya gazeta. 1888. № 42. 5 iyunya. S. 4–5.
 Klements 1888v – Klements D. Nagovory i primety u krest'yan Minusinskogo okruga: materialy dlya izucheniya mirosozertsaniya sibirskogo sel'skogo naseleniya // Izvestiya Vostochno-Sibirskogo otdela Imperatorskogo russkogo geograficheskogo obschestva. 1888. T. XIX. № 3. S. 27–45.
 Klements 1889 – Klements D.A. Predvaritel'nye svedeniya ob ehkskursii D.A. Klementsa v Achinskij i Kanskij okruga // Izvestiya Vostochno-Sibirskogo otdela Imperatorskogo russkogo geograficheskogo obschestva. 1889. T. XX. № 1. S. 43–69.
 Klements 1891a – Klements D. Golos iz provintsii // Vostochnoe obozrenie. 1891. № 24. 9 iyunya. S. 7–10.
 Klements 1891b – D.K. Pis'ma s russkoj granitsy // Vostochnoe obozrenie. 1891. № 46. 10 noyabrya. S. 12–13.
 Klements 1892 – D.K. Pis'ma s russkoj granitsy // Vostochnoe obozrenie. 1892. № 2. 12 yanvarya. S. 9–10.
 Klements 1907a – Klements D.A. Pessimizm na buryatskoj pochve // Sibirskie voprosy. 1907. № 10. S. 7–23.
 Klements 1907b – Klements D. Predislovie k russkomu izdaniyu // Shurts G. Istoriya pervobytnoj kul'tury. SPb.: Tipografiya knigoizdatel'skogo t-va “Prosveschenie”, 1907. S. VII–XIV.
 Klements 1908a – Klements D.A. Zametki o kochevom byte // Sibirskie voprosy. 1908. № 49–52. S. 7–57.
 Klements 1908b – Klements D.A. Naselenie Sibiri // Sibir'. Ee sovremennoe sostoyanie i nuzhdy / Pod red. I. S. Mel'nika. SPb.: Izdanie A.F. Devriena, 1908. S. 37–78.
 Klements, Khangalov 1910 – Klements D.A., Khangalov M.N. Obschestvennye okhoty u severnykh buryat (zehgehteh-aba – okhota na rosomakh) // Materialy po ehtnografii Rossii. T. 1 / Pod red. F.K. Volkova. SPb.: Ehtnograficheskij otdel Russkogo muzeya imp. Aleksandra III, 1910. S. 117–154.
 OGKU GAIO – Oblastnoe gosudarstvennoe kazennoe uchrezhdenie “Gosudarstvennyj arkhiv Irkutskoj oblasti”. F. 293. Op. 1. OTs.
 Sibiryakov 1916 – Pis'mo I.M. Sibiryakova k D.A. Klementsu // Izvestiya Vostochno-Sibirskogo otdela Imperatorskogo russkogo geograficheskogo obschestva. 1916. T. XLV. S. 157–161.
 Klementz 1910 – Klementz D. Buriats // Encyclopaedia of Religion and Ethics. Vol. III. / Ed. J. Hastings. Edinburgh: T. & T. Clark, 1910. P. 1–17.
 Klementz 1913 – Klementz D. Gilyaks // Encyclopaedia of Religion and Ethics. Vol. VI / Ed. J. Hastings. Edinburgh: T. & T. Clark, 1913. P. 221–226.
 Arkhipova A.I. Gubernatorskaya vlast' i politika v otnoshenii inorodcheskogo naseleniya narubezhe XIX–XX vv. v Yakutskoj oblasti // Vlast' i upravlenie na Vostoke Rossii. 2011. № 4 (57). S. 114–117.
 Berdinskikh V.A. Uezdnye istoriki: russkaya provintsial'naya istoriografiya. M.: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, 2003.
 Dzherasi R. Kul'turnaya sud'ba imperii pod voprosom: musul'manskij Vostok v rossijskoj ehtnografii XIX v. // Novaya imperskaya istoriya postsovetskogo prostranstva / Pod red. I.V. Gerasimova i dr. Kazan': Tsentr issledovanij natsionalizma i imperii, 2004. S. 271–306.
 Litvinchuk M.S., Panchenko A.B. Obschestvennyj deyatel', revolyutsioner ili uchenyj – obraz D.A. Klementsa v sovetskoj i sovremennoj otechestvennoj istoriografii // Vestnik Surgutskogo gosudarstvennogo pedagogicheskogo universiteta. 2014. № 4 (31). S. 141–147.
 Milevskij O.A. Geografiya i politika: tsentral'noaziatskaya problematika v nauchnom nasledii D.A. Klementsa // Problemy natsional'noj strategii. 2015. № 5 (32). S. 204–223.
 Mogil'ner M. Homo imperii: ocherki istorii fizicheskoj antropologii v Rossii. M.: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, 2008.
 Najt N. O russkom orientalizme: otvet Adibu Khalidu // Rossijskaya imperiya v zarubezhnoj istoriografii. Raboty poslednikh let / Pod red. O. Leont'evoj. M.: Novye granitsy, 2005. S. 323–343.
 Nikolaev V.N. Yakutskij kraj i ego issledovateli. Vyp. I. Kratkij istoricheskij ocherk ehkspeditsij v Yakutskuyu oblast'. 1632–1913 gg. Yakutsk: Tipografiya gazety “Yakutskaya okraina”, 1913.
 Slezkin Yu. Arkticheskie zerkala: Rossiya i malye narody Severa. M.: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, 2008.
 Skhimmel'pennink van der Oje D. Navstrechu Voskhodyaschemu solntsu: kak imperskoe mifotvorchestvo privelo Rossiyu k vojne s Yaponiej. M.: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, 2009.
 Todorova M. Est' li russkaya dusha u russkogo orientalizma? Dopolnenie k sporu Nataniehlya Najta i Adiba Khalida // Rossijskaya imperiya v zarubezhnoj istoriografii. Raboty poslednikh let / Pod red. O. Leont'evoj. M.: Novye granitsy, 2005. S. 344–359.
 Tokarev S.A. Istoriya russkoj ehtnografii (dooktyabr'skij period). M.: Nauka, 1966.
 Fedorova V.I. Revolyutsionnyj narodnik, uchenyj i prosvetitel' D.A. Klements. Krasnoyarsk: Izd-vo Krasnoyarskogo un-ta, 1988.
 Khalid A. Rossijskaya istoriya i spor ob orientalizme // Rossijskaya imperiya v zarubezhnoj istoriografii. Raboty poslednikh let / Pod red. O. Leont'evoj. M.: Novye granitsy, 2005. S. 310–322.
 Shorokhova T.S. Blagotvoritel' Innokentij Sibiryakov: biograficheskie povestvovaniya. SPb.: Izd-vo Sankt-Peterburgskogo un-ta, 2005.
 Ehtkind A. Vnutrennyaya kolonizatsiya. Imperskij opyt Rossii. M.: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, 2013.